SMT and THT Components: Analysis

fpsupdate

13 mins ago

Many designs include both SMT and THT components.

Many PCBs require that you choose the best SMT and THT components for your design

Choosing between surface-mount technology (SMT) and through-hole technology (THT) components is a critical decision that directly impacts PCB design success, manufacturing costs, and product reliability. In many cases, your design will include both types. Therefore, understanding the fundamental differences between SMT and THT components is crucial to selecting the best components, which will also determine the manufacturing requirements to optimize the assembly of your PCB.

Understanding SMT and THT Component Attributes

Many through-hole and surface mount devices (SMDs) have similar performance profiles. In fact, most major manufacturers produce both types, especially when it comes to passive components. Consequently, you must look beyond electrical characteristics to determine which is the best option for your design. The following are some important differentiating factors to consider.

Attributes of SMT and THT Components
Factor	SMT Components	THT Components
Availability	Extensive selection, dominant in the market	Limited selection for newer technologies
Cost	Lower component cost, higher setup cost	Higher component cost, lower setup cost
Ease of Manufacturing	Automated pick-and-place assembly	Manual insertion required
Component Density	High density, both-sided mounting	Low density and single-sided are typical
Mechanical Strength	Lower mechanical bond strength	Superior mechanical connection strength
Routing Complexity	Complex routing with via-in-pad capability	Simplified routing requires drilled holes
Rigid PCB Compatibility	Excellent compatibility	Excellent compatibility
Rigid-Flex PCB Compatibility	Excellent on rigid sections only	Limited, typically rigid sections only
Flex PCB Compatibility	Limited, requires careful consideration	Not recommended for flexible areas

As illustrated in the table, several factors can help you choose the right component type for your design. However, to make a fully informed decision, it is important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of both SMT and THT components.

SMT Components: Advantages and Disadvantages

👍Higher Component Density:

SMT components enable up to 60-70% PCB size reduction compared to through-hole designs. Components can be mounted on both sides of the board, maximizing space utilization for compact product designs.

👍Enhanced High-Frequency Performance:

Shorter lead lengths reduce parasitic inductance and capacitance, making SMT components ideal for high-frequency applications where signal integrity is critical.

👍Manufacturing Efficiency:

Automated pick-and-place assembly significantly increases production speed while reducing labor costs. The highly automated SMT process enables consistent, repeatable manufacturing at scale.

👍Cost-Effective Production:

While the initial equipment investment is substantial, SMT assembly offers lower per-unit costs through automation, material savings, and increased throughput for high-volume production.

👎Complex Repair Requirements:

SMT component repair demands specialized equipment, including hot air rework stations and microscopes, which increases maintenance complexity and costs.

👎High Initial Investment:

Setting up SMT assembly lines requires significant capital investment in pick-and-place machines, reflow ovens, and inspection equipment, creating barriers for smaller manufacturers.

👎Environmental Sensitivity:

SMT components exhibit increased susceptibility to mechanical stress and thermal cycling compared to through-hole alternatives, which can potentially impact their reliability in harsh operating conditions.

👎Manual Assembly Challenges:

The small size of SMT components makes manual prototyping and small-batch assembly difficult without specialized tools and techniques.

THT Components: Advantages and Disadvantages

👍Superior Mechanical Strength:
THT components create robust mechanical bonds by passing their pins through the PCB and soldering on both sides. This construction provides exceptional resistance to mechanical stress, vibration, and physical shock.

👍Simplified Prototyping:
Larger component size and 0.100″ or greater lead spacing facilitate easy manual assembly, making THT ideal for prototyping and small-batch production without specialized equipment.

👍High-Power Capability:
THT components accommodate higher currents and voltages compared to SMT alternatives, making them essential for power electronics and high-voltage applications.

👍Environmental Reliability:
Robust construction and strong mechanical connections provide superior performance in extreme temperatures, humidity, and challenging environmental conditions typical in industrial and aerospace applications.

👎Increased PCB Size:
The drilled holes and larger component footprints result in significantly larger board sizes, limiting miniaturization potential for compact device designs.

👎Higher Production Costs:
Manual or semi-automated assembly processes increase the labor costs and production time compared to automated SMT manufacturing. Material costs are also higher due to larger component sizes and PCB requirements.

👎Limited Component Density:
Drilling requirements and spacing constraints limit the number of components per unit area, reducing the overall circuit complexity potential.

👎Slower Manufacturing:
THT assembly involves time-intensive manual component insertion followed by wave soldering, resulting in slower production rates compared to automated SMT processes.

Guidelines for Choosing Between SMT and THT Component Types

As discussed above, there are many factors and comparison criteria to consider when choosing between SMT and THT components. To best put this understanding into practice, we have provided guidelines that you can use to base your selection process.

SMT and THT Components: Selection Guidelines

Select SMT for high-volume production requiring automated assembly, cost optimization, and compact form factors typical in consumer electronics and mobile devices.
Choose THT for high-power applications exceeding 5 watts or high-voltage circuits above 50V where robust mechanical connections are essential for safety and reliability.
Prioritize THT in harsh environments with extreme temperatures, vibration, or shock conditions found in industrial, automotive, and aerospace applications.
Use SMT for high-frequency designs above 100MHz where minimized parasitic effects are critical for signal integrity and electromagnetic compatibility.
Consider THT for prototyping phases when manual assembly capability and component accessibility facilitate design iteration and troubleshooting.
Implement hybrid approaches combining both technologies when designs require the benefits of each method for different circuit sections or components.
Evaluate manufacturing capabilities, including available equipment, production volumes, and workforce skills, when making technology selection decisions.
Account for repair requirements by choosing THT when field serviceability and easy component replacement are project priorities.

The choice between SMT and THT components fundamentally depends on balancing project requirements, including size constraints, power requirements, environmental conditions, production volume, and manufacturing capabilities. SMT dominates modern electronics through its superior density and automation benefits, while THT remains essential for applications that demand mechanical robustness and high-power handling. Successful PCB design depends on how well you leverage both technologies strategically to optimize performance, cost, and manufacturability for their specific application requirements.

If you’re looking for CAD models for common components or important information on how to choose between SMT and THT components, Ultra Librarian helps by compiling all your sourcing and CAD information in one place.

Working with Ultra Librarian sets up your team for success to ensure streamlined and error-free design, production, and sourcing. Register today for free.