GaN vs SiC vs Si: Benefits and Differences

Knowing the benefits and differences of GaN vs SiC vs Si allows you to make the best selection for your semiconductor

Today, selecting the best components for your design involves considering the materials that define semiconductor performance. Modern semiconductor technology has evolved beyond traditional silicon (Si) to include advanced wide bandgap materials, like gallium nitride (GaN) and silicon carbide (SiC). As engineers design increasingly sophisticated power electronics, understanding the fundamental differences between these three semiconductor materials becomes crucial for selecting the optimal components.

Comparing GaN vs SiC vs Si Semiconductor Materials

Not that long ago, silicon was virtually the only viable semiconductor material choice. Those days are over. Today, when choosing the best device for your design, consider all three leading options: GaN vs SiC vs Si. Doing so requires an understanding of the differences in properties and typical applications, as listed below.

GaN vs SiC vs Si Comparison
Property	Silicon (Si)	Silicon Carbide (SiC)	Gallium Nitride (GaN)
Energy Band Gap	1.1 eV	3.2-3.3 eV	3.4 eV
Temperature Sensitivity	150°C max operating	200°C+ operating range	200°C+ operating range
Electrical Conductivity	1,450 cm²/V·s (electron mobility)	650-900 cm²/V·s (electron mobility)	1,500-2,000 cm²/V·s (electron mobility)
Thermal Conductivity	150 W/m·K	490 W/m·K	130 W/m·K
N-Type Doping Capability	Excellent (phosphorus, arsenic)	Good (nitrogen)	Excellent (silicon)
P-Type Doping Capability	Excellent (boron)	Challenging (aluminum)	Difficult (magnesium)
Electron Mobility	1,450 cm²/V·s	650-900 cm²/V·s	1,500-2,000 cm²/V·s
Relative Cost	Low (baseline)	Medium-High (3-5x Si)	High (5-10x Si)
Availability	Excellent	Good	Growing
Best Applications	General-purpose electronics, low-power devices	High-power, high-temperature applications	High-frequency, high-efficiency power conversion

Silicon (Si): The Established Foundation

Silicon remains the cornerstone of semiconductor technology, offering several key advantages over wide bandgap alternatives. Its mature manufacturing ecosystem provides unmatched cost-effectiveness and component availability, making it ideal for high-volume applications where cost optimization is paramount.

Silicon Advantages Compared to GaN and SiC

Manufacturing Maturity: Silicon benefits from decades of process optimization, resulting in highly refined fabrication techniques and exceptional yield rates. This maturity translates to consistent quality and predictable performance characteristics across a diverse range of operating conditions.
Superior P-Type Doping: Unlike GaN and SiC, silicon readily accepts p-type dopants, like boron, which enables efficient complementary device structures. This characteristic proves essential for CMOS logic applications where both n-type and p-type devices must perform optimally within the same circuit.
Cost Effectiveness: Silicon’s abundant raw material availability and established supply chain infrastructure maintain its position as the most economical semiconductor option. For applications not requiring extreme operating conditions, silicon’s cost advantage often outweighs the performance benefits of wide bandgap materials.
Design Ecosystem: It is essential to employ essential design guidelines to maximize the effectiveness of your Si components and PCBs.

Silicon Carbide (SiC): High-Power Performance Leader

Silicon carbide emerges as the preferred choice for demanding power electronics applications, particularly where high temperature operation and superior thermal management are critical. SiC’s wide 3.2-3.3 eV bandgap enables operation at voltages and temperatures that would destroy silicon devices.

SiC Advantages Compared to GaN and Si

Superior Thermal Management: SiC’s thermal conductivity of 490 W/m·K significantly exceeds both silicon (150 W/m·K) and GaN (130 W/m·K), enabling more effective heat dissipation in high-power applications. This thermal advantage allows for more compact designs with smaller heat sinks and cooling systems.
High-Voltage Capability: SiC devices routinely operate at voltages exceeding 1,200V, with some applications reaching 6,500V or higher. This voltage handling capability surpasses silicon’s typical 600V limit and exceeds GaN’s practical voltage range in most commercial applications.
Temperature Resilience: SiC maintains stable performance characteristics at junction temperatures exceeding 200°C, compared to silicon’s 150°C limit. This temperature tolerance proves invaluable in automotive, industrial, and aerospace applications where ambient temperatures and power dissipation create challenging operating conditions.
Mature Wide Bandgap Technology: Among wide bandgap semiconductors, SiC technology has achieved greater manufacturing maturity compared to GaN, resulting in better availability and more predictable supply chains. Many top semiconductor manufacturers have established robust SiC production capabilities.

Gallium Nitride (GaN): High-Frequency Innovation

Gallium nitride represents the cutting edge of semiconductor technology, offering exceptional electron mobility and switching performance that enable revolutionary advances in power conversion efficiency and frequency response.

GaN Advantages Compared to SiC and Si

Exceptional Electron Mobility: GaN’s electron mobility of 1,500-2,000 cm²/V·s significantly exceeds that of SiC (650-900 cm²/V·s) and approaches the levels of silicon while maintaining a much wider bandgap. This high mobility enables faster switching speeds and reduced conduction losses.
Superior Switching Performance: GaN devices achieve switching frequencies in the MHz range with minimal losses, compared to kHz-range operation typical of silicon and SiC devices. This high-frequency capability enables dramatic reductions in passive component size, particularly inductors and capacitors in switch-mode power supplies.
Power Density Advantages: The combination of high switching frequency and efficient power conversion allows GaN-based designs to achieve power densities 3-5 times higher than those of silicon equivalents. This advantage proves particularly valuable in applications where size and weight constraints are critical.
Integration Capabilities: GaN technology enables monolithic integration of power devices with control circuitry, as demonstrated by components like the Texas Instruments LMG3622REQR available in Ultra Librarian’s component library. This 650V GaN FET integrates driver, protection, and current sensing functions in a single package.

TI LMG3622REQR GaN field-effect transistor (FET)

Optimizing Your Semiconductor Selection

When selecting the best semiconductor and deciding between GaN, SiC, and Si for your project, consider these critical selection criteria:

Criterion for Choosing Between GaN vs SiC vs Si

Power Level Requirements:
Silicon works well for low to moderate power applications (under 1kW), SiC excels in high-power applications (1kW-100kW+), while GaN optimizes medium-power, high-efficiency applications (100W-10kW).
Frequency Considerations:
For switching frequencies above 100kHz, GaN provides superior performance. SiC operates effectively in the 10-100kHz range, while silicon remains suitable for lower frequencies.
Operating Temperature:
Applications requiring operation above 150°C necessitate the use of SiC or GaN. Silicon suffices for standard temperature ranges.
Voltage Requirements:
Silicon handles voltages up to 600V efficiently, SiC enables operation from 600V to 6.5kV+, and GaN typically operates in the 100-650V range with optimal performance.
Cost Sensitivity:
Silicon offers the lowest initial component cost, SiC provides moderate pricing with high-power capabilities, and GaN commands premium pricing for specialized applications.
Size and Weight Constraints:
GaN enables the most compact designs due to its high switching frequencies, while SiC offers good power density for high-voltage applications, and silicon requires larger passive components.
Availability and Supply Chain:
Silicon maintains the most robust supply chain; SiC availability continues to improve with major manufacturer investments, and GaN supply remains limited but is growing rapidly.

The semiconductor material selection process should also account for the broader system requirements, including thermal management capabilities, electromagnetic interference considerations, and long-term reliability requirements. Ultra Librarian’s comprehensive component database provides access to manufacturer-verified models for components across all three material categories, enabling accurate design simulation and validation.

If you’re looking for CAD models for common components or important GaN vs SiC vs Si semiconductor material comparison information, Ultra Librarian helps by compiling all your sourcing and CAD information in one place.

Working with Ultra Librarian sets up your team for success to ensure streamlined and error-free design, production, and sourcing. Register today for free.